Ok they are smelly but it has never bothered me - and frankly my dog will only eat the ones that are super smelly. The small size is perfect for my dog and a bag lasts a little less than a month. Super thick and better for your dog than rawhide bones. Be careful if your dog has weight issues - these things have a high calorie content - I avoid that by using smaller bullys and using as a very special treat.

The 12 oz pack is perfect for my adult corgi. I like that they are different shapes and sizes- sometimes I don't have as much time to play with him so I give him one of the bigger ones. He seems to like them that way too. I've tried the Costco ones (same brand) and they are perfectly straight (and so long I cut them) and all about the same thickness, but my dog doesn't seem to get as excited about them. Yes they are stinky but he seems to prefer them stinky! And the smell doesn't last the whole time he chews them.

My dog loves these. She can chew it for a long time. They last a very good amount of time.

My dogs live this brand of bully sticks. They are long lasting, the thickness gives them hours of chew time. They smell terrible but my girls love the taste. Keeps them busy for hours!

I usually have trouble finding a chew stick that my dog will stick to. What I used to gave her are either abandoned or treated as toys. Since she's growing her adult teeth at this moment, she often goes after my socks, shoes, or the hem of my pants. This cadet stick solved the problem! We just got it a few days ago and our dog is busy chewing it away. Along with the delicious taste of this stick came peace. My kids and I no longer have to worry about her chewing on random things now! This is a must for dog owners.

Brief review: These are among the best value I have found thus far for quality bullies (I buy the 12oz pack). While sizes have varied a bit (I've gotten packs with fewer thick sticks, however most come with more sticks of medium thickness like the one in my photo) the pack is always 12oz so there's no skimping or anything. One thick stick lasts my dog a bit more than a day; the medium sticks I usually receive last around 3/4 day and I'll give her a second that runs well into the next day. the odor is there, but it's not as bad as some of the others I've tried. Longer review: These are a true godsend... Our pup is a ball of energy (especially in the morning), and a 'spirited chewer'... and to make matters worse, we just had her spayed, so she now has to bottle all of her energy with no real outlet... Before her surgery, she loved her bully sticks, however they were always a bit... well... putrid... I made the mistake of switching to Himalayan yak cheese sticks since they are supposed to be another great, long lasting alternative with less odor... I still advise for you all to give the yak cheese a try, however our pooch doesn't really give them the attention we hoped she would... instead focusing her teeth on our base boards, plants, and our son.... I got my new order of these bully sticks, and things are back to fairly peaceful, even if a bit odorific!!!! No, these sticks don't train your pup not to chew your furniture or nip at children, but one chew lasts our dog an entire day of dedicated chewing, hours at a time... Our girl is small, but she has a powerful jaw (Chow / Pit / Australian Cattle Dog / German Shepherd / Collie mix). Just to note, these are definitely not odorless but they aren't as bad as some of the others I've purchased (and none are truly odorless from my experience and research). Try them out - keep your dog in another room if necessary, but you won't be sorry! May the funk be with y'all!

I purchase the 1lb bag of these bully sticks often! However the last 2-3 bags have been 90% 4 inch “tips” with only 3/4 pieces longer than 4 inches. I understand it’s a variety bag of 4-6 inches, but the ratio has been way off lately! I’ll be taking a break from this brand for a while.

Our GSP loves and is addicted to these sticks. She has 1 every evening after dinner during tv time. They do have an odor but she loves them and they are never laying about uneaten. Teeth are sparkling white with no tartar anywhere to be found. 5 paws!!