My two dogs love these treats. I usually grab them in the store vs Amazon but recently the price jumped AGAIN so I added them to my subscribe and save. Win-win! Save some money, they show up every month like clock work and my dogs love them as you can see by photo. These are in their top three favorite treats!! As long as they keep arriving fresh and not hard I’ll keep getting them from Amazon. The size and softness of these are what I like best for them. Even though they come long, they have little grooves in them so you can easily break them into smaller pieces. My dogs digest these extremely well, have no issues chewing them and never get sick from them. Always a brand I trust. Thank you for reading.

Our dogs are older, therefore picky. Pup A Roni treats have been a mainstay for years. We purchase the larger bags and they arrive on time. The bag closes easily, however they also stay fresh if a bag clip is used. Pup A Ron treats are soft and chewable. The size allows for one treat or may be broken into smaller portions. These treats are perfect for pups, older dogs and those in between.

We tested 5 kinds of soft training treats with our golden retrievers, looking for an economic soft treat that could be used for many training sessions. The ideal training treat was defined as appealing/tasty enough to be a motivating reward, as resistant as possible to crumbling when handling and carrying in the treat pouch, yet soft and small enough so the dog could consume the treat quickly and without choking at the instant that was being rewarded. We tested Howl's Kitchen Training Bites beef flavor; Pup-Peroni Minis original beef flavor in the 22.5 oz bag; Bil-Jac Vet Dogs Skin & Coat Formula chicken in the 10 oz 4-pack; Buddy Biscuits Training Bites Low Calorie Bacon 10 oz bag, and Dingo Soft & Chewy Beef/Chicken 360-Count. Right away we noticed that the Dingo and Howl's Kitchen treats were dry and hard - not soft at all. This was a shame because the Howl's Kitchen treats were a meaty-looking square nugget that looked to hold up well in pouch and easy to handle, and our tasters loved it. But we defined the need as for a soft treat, so we didn't consider these two appropriate for training. Size made a big difference too, not least to economics. One ounce of treats equalled 8 of the Bil-Jac Vet Dogs star-shaped treats , about 10 of the varying length Pupperoni Minis, and a whopping 49 of the Buddy Bites. While the Vet Dogs treats were a bit crumblier than we'd like, they were soft and the star shapes made them easy to gather from the pouch. The Pupperoni Minis were strong, but less soft and appealing to humans, although our tasters did wheelies for them. The Buddy Bites were SMALL: so tiny, think children training teacup puppies - we dropped a LOT just trying to pick some up. The verdict: When cost is everything: Buddy Bites: 1.3c/treat Best all-around treat: Pupperoni Minis: 3.5c/treat Most appealing / easy to handle: Vet Dogs: 7.8c/treat

My dog loves it, mix it with his moist dog food he eats it up. Worth buying.

My senior citizen housewolves kept barfing up freeze dried cow and chicken parts, I think because they weren't soft enough for their tender stomachs. Pup-peronis in the training morsel size are great for my dogs. They love the taste and never puke from eating them.

My dog LOVES Pupperoni, so finding this bag at a great price was a Godsend. The only issue is that openening the bag was difficult, and ruined the ability to reseal it. The treats are still great though, and my dog goes crazy for them!

Love them.

All my dogs love these. I would recommend them to anyone

My dog seems like it but it is getting dry easily !!!