I've used this brand for a few years now. It melts the snow and ice quickly (noticeable results within 15 minutes). I live in the northern suburbs of NYC, so you can compare the temperatures you have with what I've encountered (i.e., winter is often in the teens but almost never below zero Fahrenheit). Various dogs of mine have not had discomfort walking over this stuff, even though they react fairly quickly to the more common rock salt used by some of my neighbors (I use Musher's Secret on their paws in snowy weather, since they haven't liked booties, so please don't think I'm not thinking of their comfort).

Had an icy patch that sun never gets to at sidewalk and driveway. I was hesitant to put down chemicals to avoid damaging concrete and asphalt. I didn’t put down much but it was enough to melt through 3 inches of ice and I was finally able to clear the walkway. Great purchase!

Works as advertised and safe.

Nothing to complain about did the job

Melts ice and snow, doesn’t leave residue.

USELESS! Product was dripping with water and could not be used!

Worked super fast! It was -17° out and still worked! Fast too! Will definitely buy again

Contents of the bag were VERY wet making it clumpy and hard to spread. Is it supposed to be like that? I tried to use it anyway and it did not work that well unless a significant amount was applied.